Most recent edit on 2006-01-16 09:33:19 by PaulResnick

Additions:
Note: due to spammer vandalism, this site is no longer open for editing

---

Edited on 2006-01-16 09:31:53 by PaulResnick

Additions:
This site includes position papers discussed at the Beyond Threaded Conversation CHI 2005∞ Workshop on April 3, 2005. See the extended abstract∞ for a summary of what the workshop was about.
The papers all relate to online conversation systems and describe either existing systems (e.g., LiveJournal, Everything2) or prototype systems (e.g., Deme, Kontiki) that take online conversation "beyond" the traditional threaded model we are all familiar with. In addition, the site includes a draft DesignSpace document outlining some of the design issues related to online conversation. During the workshop alternative design spaces were discussed and there was no general consensus on one particular framework, but the discussion of the important factors in designing online conversation systems was informative and helped us think through how various systems relate to one another and what possibilities for design remain unexplored.
Cherny2005 - Lynn Cherny, (2005) Gakking Memes: LiveJournal �Conversation� [available here∞]
David2005 - Shay David, Geri Gay, Carl Lagoze, Bing Pan, Simeon Warner, (2005) Appraise � Beyond Threaded Conversations in Scholarly Publishing [available here∞]
Davies2005 - Todd Davies, Brendan O�Connor, Alex Cochran, Andrew Parker (2005) �Groupware for Groups�: Problem-Driven Design in Deme [available here∞]
Pontes2005 - Ad�le Malta Pontes, Clarisse Sieckenius de Souza, Simone Junqueira Barbosa, (2005) Design Requirements and Possibilities in Supporting Online Scientific Debate [available here∞]

Deletions:
This site includes position papers discussed at the Beyond Threaded Conversation CHI 2005 Workshop on April 3, 2005. The papers all relate to online conversation systems and describe either existing systems (e.g., LiveJournal, Everything2) or prototype systems (e.g., Deme, Kontiki) that take online conversation "beyond" the traditional threaded model we are all familiar with. In addition, the site includes a draft DesignSpace document outlining some of the design issues related to online conversation. During the workshop alternative design spaces were discussed and there was no general consensus on one particular framework, but the discussion of the important factors in designing online conversation systems was informative and helped us think through how various systems relate to one another and what possibilities for design remain unexplored.
Cherny2005 - Lynn Cherny, (2005) Gakking Memes: LiveJournal “Conversation” [available here∞]
David2005 - Shay David, Geri Gay, Carl Lagoze, Bing Pan, Simeon Warner, (2005) Appraise – Beyond Threaded Conversations in Scholarly Publishing [available here∞]
Davies2005 - Todd Davies, Brendan O’Connor, Alex Cochran, Andrew Parker (2005) “Groupware for Groups”: Problem-Driven Design in Deme [available here∞]
Pontes2005 - Adéle Malta Pontes, Clarisse Sieckenius de Souza, Simone Junqueira Barbosa, (2005) Design Requirements and Possibilities in Supporting Online Scientific Debate [available here∞]

---

Edited on 2005-04-05 01:11:39 by DerekHansen

No differences.

---

Edited on 2005-04-05 01:10:34 by DerekHansen

Additions:
Workshop participants, you may want to add the rss feed from the RecentChanges page to get notified when changes are made. Or, you can add the rss feed from any single page. The URL for the rss feed for any page is available by clicking on the xml icon.

Deletions:

---

Edited on 2005-04-05 01:07:41 by DerekHansen

Additions:
Note: You'll have to Login before you can make any changes to the Wiki pages. However, you don't need to in order to post comments.

Deletions:
Note: You'll have to Login before you can make any changes.

---

Edited on 2005-04-05 00:23:59 by DerekHansen

Additions:
Note: You'll have to Login before you can make any changes.

---

Edited on 2005-04-04 18:16:51 by DerekHansen

Additions:
This site will continue to be used to provide comments on workshop papers by workshop participants and the public. Feel free to post upcoming conversation-related conferences or links to other useful resources and research.
DesignSpace

Deletions:
This site will continue to be used to provide comments on workshop papers by workshop participants and the public.

---

Edited on 2005-04-04 18:11:38 by DerekHansen

Additions:
* ConversationReuse

Deletions:
* ConversationrReuse

---

Edited on 2005-04-04 18:11:21 by DerekHansen

Additions:

Welcome to the Beyond Threaded Conversation CHI2005∞ Workshop Wiki

This site includes position papers discussed at the Beyond Threaded Conversation CHI 2005 Workshop on April 3, 2005. The papers all relate to online conversation systems and describe either existing systems (e.g., LiveJournal, Everything2) or prototype systems (e.g., Deme, Kontiki) that take online conversation "beyond" the traditional threaded model we are all familiar with. In addition, the site includes a draft DesignSpace document outlining some of the design issues related to online conversation. During the workshop alternative design spaces were discussed and there was no general consensus on one particular framework, but the discussion of the important factors in designing online conversation systems was informative and helped us think through how various systems relate to one another and what possibilities for design remain unexplored.
This site will continue to be used to provide comments on workshop papers by workshop participants and the public.
Morning Breakout Session Notes
* ConversationrReuse
The following is a complete list of the most recent version of all of the accepted submissions. Each position paper has a correspending WikiPage that includes comments on the paper by other workshop participants (e.g., Bobrow2005).

Deletions:

Welcome to the Beyond Threaded Conversation CHI2005∞ workshop wiki

NOTE: location change from what was announced before: Workshop is in D134 at the Oregon Convention Center, not A106

For now, this site is only accessible to workshop participants (who have received the appropriate username and password), although after the conference we may want to make the site public. This site will be used to facilitate discussion of the position papers before the workshop is held on Sunday April 3rd, 2005. In addition, after the workshop is held we will use this space to collaboratively edit a document that summarizes our findings and outlines future work in this important area.
Before making any changes to the wiki, please login to the site using some WikiName (e.g., DerekHansen) so that it is apparent who made the changes and comments. You may also want to include your WikiName after adding substantive comments so that others know who made the comment.
NEW: DesignSpace
NEW: WorkshopSchedule
NEW: BreakoutSessions
Morning Breakout Sessions

• 5 Geek Social Fallacies -- http://www.plausiblydeniable.com/opinion/gsf.html∞

Saturday Evening Gathering
Interested in meeting up for dinner Saturday evening? Visit this page: SaturdayEveningGathering
The following is a complete list of the most recent version of all of the accepted submissions. (Note: You may have to re-enter the same username and password information that you entered to get to this site in order to download the files.) Each position paper has a correspending WikiPage that will be used for commenting on the paper by other workshop participants (e.g., Bobrow2005).

---

Edited on 2005-04-03 19:04:37 by SaraVonMosch

Additions:
InterestingNewConversationSites

---

Edited on 2005-04-03 17:59:47 by SaraVonMosch

Additions:
- 5 Geek Social Fallacies -- http://www.plausiblydeniable.com/opinion/gsf.html∞

---

Edited on 2005-04-03 17:09:24 by ToddDavies

Additions:

* DebatePediaDesign

Deletions:
- DebatePediaDesign

---

Edited on 2005-04-03 17:06:48 by ToddDavies

Additions:
- DebatePediaDesign

---

Edited on 2005-04-03 16:45:29 by SaraVonMosch

Additions:
* AudienceDesignConcerns

Deletions:
* Audiences / Design concerns

---

Edited on 2005-04-03 16:44:25 by SaraVonMosch

Additions:
Morning Breakout Sessions
* Audiences / Design concerns

---

Edited on 2005-04-03 11:43:00 by ToddDavies

Additions:

NOTE: location change from what was announced before: Workshop is in D134 at the Oregon Convention Center, not A106

Deletions:

NOTE: location change from what was announced before: Workshop is in D134 at the Oregon Convention Center, note A106

---

Edited on 2005-04-03 11:42:12 by ToddDavies [noted correct location: D106]

Additions:

NOTE: location change from what was announced before: Workshop is in D134 at the Oregon Convention Center, note A106

---

Edited on 2005-04-02 19:38:22 by 12.154.193.77 [added by Scott Golder]

Additions:
Saturday Evening Gathering Interested in meeting up for dinner Saturday evening? Visit this page: SaturdayEveningGathering

---

Edited on 2005-04-02 04:29:53 by DerekHansen

Additions:
NEW: DesignSpace

---

Oldest known version of this page was edited on 2005-04-02 04:26:34 by DerekHansen []

For now, this site is only accessible to workshop participants (who have received the appropriate username and password), although after the conference we may want to make the site public. This site will be used to facilitate discussion of the position papers before the workshop is held on Sunday April 3rd, 2005. In addition, after the workshop is held we will use this space to collaboratively edit a document that summarizes our findings and outlines future work in this important area.

Before making any changes to the wiki, please login to the site using some WikiName (e.g., DerekHansen) so that it is apparent who made the changes and comments. You may also want to include your WikiName after adding substantive comments so that others know who made the comment.

NEW: WorkshopSchedule
NEW: BreakoutSessions

---

Workshop Organizers:
DerekHansen
PaulResnick
MarkAckerman
JohnRiedl
LorenTerveen

---

The following is a complete list of the most recent version of all of the accepted submissions. (Note: You may have to re-enter the same username and password information that you entered to get to this site in order to download the files.) Each position paper has a correspending WikiPage that will be used for commenting on the paper by other workshop participants (e.g., Bobrow2005).

Position Papers

All Submissions as Zip File∞

Individual Submissions

Ackerman2005 - Mark S. Ackerman, Stephen Cotterill, Kevin Nam, (2005) From Community Discussion to Knowledge Distillation:
The I-DIAG Research Project [available here∞]

Bobrow2005 - Daniel G. Bobrow, Bob Cheslow, Elizabeth Churchill, Les Nelson, Jack Whalen, (2005) Conversation Support in a Collaboration Space for a Distributed Workgroup [available here∞]

Cherny2005 - Lynn Cherny, (2005) Gakking Memes: LiveJournal “Conversation” [available here∞]

Dave2005 - Kushal Dave, (2005) REALM: Restructuring online conversations [available here∞]

David2005 - Shay David, Geri Gay, Carl Lagoze, Bing Pan, Simeon Warner, (2005) Appraise – Beyond Threaded Conversations in Scholarly Publishing [available here∞]

Davies2005 - Todd Davies, Brendan O’Connor, Alex Cochran, Andrew Parker (2005) “Groupware for Groups”: Problem-Driven Design in Deme [available here∞]

DeMaagd2005 - Kurt DeMaagd, Cliff Lampe, (2005) Everything2: Cataloging All Human Knowledge [available here∞]

Donath2005 - Judith Donath, (2005) Words as Landscape [available here∞]

Erickson2005 - Thomas Erickson, (2005) Visualizing Talk: A Re-Design of the Scenarios System [available here∞]

Golder2005 - Scott A. Golder, Judith Donath, (2005) Content as Conversation Space: Promoting Positive Contributions Through Vetted Annotations [available here∞]

Hansen2005 - Derek Hansen (2005) Health FACTS: From Conversation to Archive and Back Again [available here∞]

Hupfer2005 - Susanne Hupfer, Li-Te Cheng, Steven Ross, John Patterson, (2005) Reinventing Team Spaces for a Collaborative Development Environment [available here∞]

Medynskiy2005 - Yevgeniy Medynskiy, (2005) Implicit Links in Asynchronous Communication Spaces [available here∞]

Pontes2005 - Adéle Malta Pontes, Clarisse Sieckenius de Souza, Simone Junqueira Barbosa, (2005) Design Requirements and Possibilities in Supporting Online Scientific Debate [available here∞]

Rodriguez2005 - Henrry Rodriguez, Kerstin Severinson Eklundh, (2005) Conversation around documents: more than threading [available here∞]

Smith2005 - Marc A. Smith, (2005) Enhanced interfaces for threaded conversations [available here∞]

VonMosch2005 - Sara von Mosch, (2005) ConversationLens: Towards Personalized Online Conversation [available here∞]

Wattenberg2005 - Martin Wattenberg, Jonathan Feinberg, (2005) Kontiki: A Wiki for People and Processes [available here∞]

Windram2005 - Elizabeth Windram, (2005) weblog: An Interactive Space for Engaging in Shared Experiences at a Distance [available here∞]

Yee2005 - Ka-Ping Yee, Marti Hearst, (2005) A Visualization to Facilitate Productive Discussions [available here∞]

Zhou2005 - Liang Zhou, Eduard Hovy, (2005) Fine-grained Clustering for Summarizing Chat Logs [available here∞]

Zinman2005 - Aaron Zinman, Judith Donath, (2005) RadioActive: enabling mobile-based audio forums [available here∞]

---

Here are a few useful pages: FormattingRules, OrphanedPages, WantedPages, TextSearch.

Questions or comments about the site? Please email shakmatt@umich.edu